I'm an Expat With Investments Around the World. Why Does My U.S. Tax Return Have So Many Forms?

How PFIC reporting, foreign accounts and multiple countries complicate a U.S. expat tax return

How PFIC reporting, foreign accounts and multiple countries complicate a U.S. expat tax return

Renee Mizrahi, EA, CFE

Founder, TaxJet

If you hold foreign funds, property, or bank accounts in more than one country, the IRS still wants to know about all of it, and each piece can add its own form to your U.S. return. This is the story of Falco, an expat with no real home base who moves around the world as comfortably as if it were his own neighborhood, until his own success led him straight into the IRS rules on PFICs and multi-country reporting.


Falco set his phone face down on the wooden counter of the sushi restaurant in Tokyo. Beside his matcha drink lay a loose scatter of cash: crisp U.S. hundred-dollar bills next to freshly withdrawn Japanese yen. He had just wrapped up one last call, and he was ready to enjoy his dinner without talking business.


Falco is sharp, wealthy, and an expat with no real place he calls home. He moved between Milan, Singapore, Tokyo, and wherever else caught his interest with the ease of someone walking down his own street. He took Ubers everywhere, checked into five-star hotels without thinking twice, and did business wherever he landed.


Across town, his oldest friend Kree was asleep in an eleven-dollar capsule hotel with a curtain that kept sliding open. Kree was a digital nomad normally based on a Thai island who loved traveling and worked hard to make it happen: a laptop, a remote job, and one bag she could carry anywhere. Kree moved around because she loved the adventure and figured out how to afford it along the way. Neither of them thought the other had gotten it wrong.


A few times a year their routes crossed and they met up just for fun. Tomorrow they were catching an early train north to go skiing in Hokkaido. Kree had mapped out the trip months ago. Falco had agreed to it in five seconds.


Before heading up to the mountains, though, Falco had one piece of unfinished business to sort out. Over the years, his success had left a trail: index funds he bought through a broker in Ireland, an investment flat in Lisbon he picked up when the euro dipped, a rental property in Milan, and bank accounts in more places than he could name at a glance. Everything he owned was straightforward on paper. It had simply grown across too many borders to eyeball anymore.


Earlier that evening, Falco had mentioned to Sal that he was pulling together his records for U.S. tax season.

Sal, a mutual friend who had opinions about everything and a dangerous amount of confidence, had laughed it off.

"You're creating work for yourself," Sal had told him on the phone. "You don't even live in one place, and if the money never touches a U.S. bank account, the IRS has no idea it exists. Just report whatever hits your American account and leave the rest where it sits."


Falco hadn't built his wealth by taking sloppy advice, and he knew better than to trust a tax shortcut from Sal. What actually concerned him were the index funds he had picked up through his Irish broker, along with how his overseas accounts and properties interacted on a U.S. return.


Before the night was over, Falco turned his phone back over and got on a video call with Ida.

Ida, the small, silver-haired tax preparer in the brown suit who had been doing expat returns for forty years, already had her yellow legal pad ready.


"Sal thinks that because I don't have a fixed home base and keep my foreign money overseas, none of it belongs on my U.S. return," Falco said, pulling up a clean summary of his holdings. "I know better than that. What I want to look at closely are the index funds I bought in Ireland, along with my investment flat in Lisbon, the rental in Milan, and the bank accounts."


Ida gave a small nod. She liked clients who came in with their eyes open.

"You're right to ignore Sal, and you're smart to take a closer look at the Irish funds first," Ida said, writing PFIC at the top of her pad. "As a U.S. citizen, you are taxed on your worldwide income whether you live in New York or move between hotels every month. And when you buy non-U.S. mutual funds or ETFs, the IRS almost always classifies them as Passive Foreign Investment Companies, or PFICs."


Falco leaned forward. "They're just standard, broad-market index funds. Nothing exotic."

"That's what catches almost every smart investor who buys funds overseas," Ida said. "Under U.S. tax law, it doesn't matter how plain the fund is. If it's domiciled outside the United States, it falls into the PFIC regime. That means punitive tax rates on gains and distributions, daily interest charges, and a separate Form 8621 for each fund."


"That's a heavy penalty for buying an index fund," Falco said. "What about the Lisbon flat? If I sell it for the same 300,000 euros I paid, there's no gain on the property."


"In euros, there isn't," Ida said, jotting down two exchange rates. "In U.S. dollars, there can be. The IRS converts your purchase price using the exchange rate on the day you bought it, and your sale price using the rate on the day you sold it. If the euro strengthened against the dollar while you held it, the IRS sees a taxable capital gain even if the local price never moved."


Falco studied his notes for a second. "So between the PFIC rules on the funds and currency movement on the property, the tax code penalizes structures that look completely normal outside the U.S. What about the income taxes I've already paid in Europe?"


"That's where we protect you," Ida said, tapping her pen against the pad. "Between the Foreign Tax Credit on Form 1116 and U.S. tax treaties, we can offset the income taxes you've already paid abroad so you aren't paying twice. Pair that with an FBAR and Form 8938 to disclose the accounts properly, and we can look at whether a QEF or mark-to-market election makes sense for those Irish funds."


"That's four extra forms before we even get to the return itself," Falco said.


She flipped the top sheet of her yellow legal pad over.

"Send me the year-end statements for every fund and bank account, the rental records in Milan, and the dates and figures on that Lisbon flat," Ida said. "You built a great setup. Now let's make sure the paperwork keeps up with it."


Falco promised to send everything after his ski trip with Kree. The taxes would just have to wait this time. He ended the call, turned his phone face down on the counter again, and ordered mochi and a hot tea.

The story pauses here. Here is what the law actually says.

The IRS taxes U.S. citizens on their worldwide income, and money spread across several countries adds forms and traps on top of the tax itself. The three that catch people most often are foreign funds that count as passive foreign investment companies (PFICs), foreign property sales that are calculated in U.S. dollars, and double taxation that only goes away when the credits are claimed correctly.

Does the IRS Tax Income I Earn in Other Countries?

Yes. U.S. citizens and resident aliens are taxed on income from all sources, wherever they live (IRC §61; IRS Publication 54). Living abroad does not end the filing requirement. It adds forms. For someone with accounts, funds and property in several countries, a multi-country expat tax return can include an FBAR, Form 8938, Form 8621 and Form 1116.

Are Foreign Mutual Funds and ETFs Treated Differently?

Yes, and this surprises investors more than almost anything else. Most mutual funds, index funds and ETFs organized outside the United States are passive foreign investment companies, or PFICs (IRC §1297). Under the default rules, a gain on sale or a large distribution is spread over every year you held the fund. Each year's share is taxed at the highest ordinary rate, plus interest (IRC §1291).


Each PFIC generally needs its own Form 8621 in any year you sell, receive a large distribution, or make an election. There is an exception for small holdings: if all your PFIC stock is worth $25,000 or less at year end ($50,000 on a joint return) and you had no gain or excess distribution, you may not need to file for that year (Instructions for Form 8621).

Can I Avoid the PFIC Rules?

Sometimes. A Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) election or a mark-to-market election can give a more predictable result than the default rules (IRC §1295; IRC §1296). Both depend on the fund. A QEF election needs the fund to give you annual statements, and mark-to-market only works for shares regularly traded on a qualifying exchange. Many foreign funds meet neither test, which is why many Americans abroad stick to U.S.-domiciled funds. Check before you buy, not after.

How Is the Sale of Foreign Property Taxed?

In U.S. dollars, not in euros or yen. You convert what you paid at the exchange rate on the purchase date, convert what you sold for at the rate on the sale date, and tax the difference. If the foreign currency rose against the dollar while you owned the property, you can owe U.S. tax on a gain that does not exist in local terms.


Here is a simple example. A flat bought for €300,000 when €1 equaled $1.10 has a U.S. cost of $330,000. Sold for the same €300,000 when €1 equals $1.20, it brings in $360,000. The flat did not go up in price, but the U.S. gain is $30,000.


Two related points. If the property was your main home, the home sale exclusion may reduce the gain (IRC §121). And a mortgage in a foreign currency is treated as its own transaction, so paying it off can create a separate currency gain or loss.

Will I Pay Tax Twice on the Same Income?

Not if the credits and treaties are used correctly, but neither works on its own. The Foreign Tax Credit (Form 1116) reduces your U.S. tax by income tax you paid to another country on the same income (IRC §901). Income tax treaties can lower or shift the tax on pensions, dividends and property gains. The credit has to be claimed, the right forms filed, and each foreign pension checked on its own, because the type of plan decides how it is reported. Some may need Form 3520 or Form 8938.

What Do I Have to Report About Foreign Accounts?

Two separate reports. The FBAR (FinCEN Form 114) is due when the combined highest balances of all your foreign accounts passed $10,000 at any time in the year (31 USC §5314). Form 8938 is filed with your tax return and has higher thresholds: for an unmarried filer living abroad, more than $200,000 on the last day of the year or $300,000 at any time (IRC §6038D). FATCA agreements mean many foreign banks report accounts held by U.S. persons directly to the IRS, so these accounts are rarely invisible. Our FBAR story walks through the first one.


Find your plan and get your taxes started today.

The Bottom Line

U.S. citizens are taxed on worldwide income wherever they live (IRC §61). Foreign mutual funds and ETFs are generally PFICs, taxed under the default rules at the highest ordinary rate plus interest unless a QEF or mark-to-market election applies, and each is reported on Form 8621 (IRC §§1291, 1295 and 1296; Instructions for Form 8621). Gain on foreign property is computed in U.S. dollars using the exchange rate on the purchase date and the rate on the sale date, so currency movement becomes part of the gain. The Foreign Tax Credit and income tax treaties prevent double taxation only when they are claimed correctly (IRC §901). Foreign accounts may require an FBAR (31 USC §5314) and Form 8938 (IRC §6038D).

“A plain index fund bought overseas is a PFIC to the IRS, and each one can mean its own Form 8621.”

Share this post

Share this post

Renee Mizrahi, EA, CFE

Our founder spent twenty years in U.S. tax practice. But something shifted when her daughters began living abroad permanently: Nepal, Cambodia, Thailand, Israel, France, and a long list of places she has genuinely lost track of.

In this story

Falco, Kree, Sal, and Ida are fictional characters created to make real tax situations easier to understand. The law in every post is accurate. This post is not tax advice, and reading it does not create a client relationship. Your facts are your own. Contact TaxJet for advice on your situation.

Enjoyed Falco’s story?

Falco is just one of the characters working through cross-border tax rules in our story series. Meet Falco & Kree and the rest of the cast to see how other real-world tax situations play out.

More from Falco & Kree

Work with TaxJet

Follow TaxJet

TaxJet on LinkedIn
TaxJet on Facebook
TaxJet on Instagram

Not sure where to start?

Get our free guide: 5 things every American abroad must know before tax season.

Get our free guide: 5 things every American abroad must know before tax season.

Get our free guide: 5 things every American abroad must know before tax season.

We’ll email your copy. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.