The IRS Rejected My Wife's Foreign Income Exclusion. Can We Just Switch to the Credit This Year?
Part 2 of 3 in the series: When the IRS Changes Your Return.
Van is the kind of person who does his own research before asking a question.
So by the time he sat down to talk through Queenie's IRS notice, he had already spent an evening reading about the Foreign Tax Credit. He had a rough sense of how it worked. He had done some mental math. And he had arrived at what felt like a logical conclusion.
"If the exclusion is not available this year," he said, "can't we just use the credit instead? And then go back to the exclusion next year when she qualifies again?"
It is a reasonable question. It is also, in most circumstances, the wrong move.
The story pauses here. Here is what the law actually says.
Two Tools, One Problem
Both the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (Form 2555, IRC Section 911) and the Foreign Tax Credit (Form 1116, IRC Section 901) exist to prevent double taxation. They just work very differently.
The exclusion removes a portion of your foreign earned income from US taxation entirely: up to $130,000 for 2025. It only works on earned income. The credit gives you a dollar-for-dollar credit against your US tax bill for foreign taxes already paid, applies more broadly, and unused credits carry forward for up to ten years.
The Election You Made Without Knowing It
When Queenie filed Form 2555 for the first time, she made an election under IRC Section 911. Under Section 911(e)(2), once you voluntarily revoke the FEIE election, you cannot make it again for five years without written IRS consent. That consent is not easy to get. It requires a private letter ruling request.
The Distinction That Saves the Election
Failing to qualify because the tests were not met is not the same as voluntarily revoking. If the IRS disallowed Queenie's exclusion because she was only abroad for 83 days and genuinely did not qualify, her election is dormant, not revoked. The moment she re-qualifies, she can pick up where she left off.
The risk comes if someone responds to the notice by filing an amendment that removes Form 2555 and substitutes the credit in a year where she arguably could have qualified. That can be treated as a voluntary revocation. Five-year clock. Started silently. Nobody sends a letter announcing it.
Bottom Line
The FEIE election under IRC Section 911 is not freely interchangeable with the Foreign Tax Credit. Under IRC Section 911(e)(2), voluntarily revoking the FEIE election starts a five-year period during which the exclusion cannot be reclaimed without IRS consent via private letter ruling. Failing to qualify because the physical presence or bona fide residence tests were not met does not revoke the election. It stays dormant. Filing an amended return that removes Form 2555 in a year where the taxpayer arguably qualified can be treated as a voluntary revocation. Get professional guidance before amending any return that touches the FEIE election. Find your plan at taxjet.co.
Filed under
Forms & Filings
Renee Mizrahi, EA, CFE
Our founder spent twenty years in U.S. tax practice. But something shifted when her daughters began living abroad permanently: Nepal, Cambodia, Thailand, Israel, France, and a long list of places she has genuinely lost track of.
Queenie, Van, and the people in their lives are fictional characters created to make real tax situations easier to understand. The law in every post is accurate. Nothing here is advice for your specific situation.
Work with TaxJet
Follow TaxJet
Not sure where to start?
We’ll email your copy. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.